The preliminary alcohol screening device (PAS) is used by law enforcement when they pull vehicles over when they feel like somebody is kind of borderline intoxicated. That’s usually when I see it used. They can use it whenever they want, but obviously, if somebody is falling down drunk, they really don’t need to use the PAS device. They can just bring them into the station in Los Angeles and they can administer the Intoxilyzer 3000 alcohol test where they blow into a tube. It registers. There’s a little receipt that’s spit out and is placed in the paperwork that’s given to the prosecutor and the defense to show what the person’s blood alcohol level was. But, if it’s close and they end up arresting somebody and taking them in and they blow like a .05 for example, that case is not likely going to be filed by the prosecutor, so now they just wasted their time. They may not even send that type of a case to the prosecutors. So, what they do is use that little preliminary alcohol screening device, which is a hand-held device that they carry around with them in the car and if somebody blows over the legal limit of that, then the police feel confident to bring them into the station and let them blow into the machine at the station.
A lot of times what I see happening is people get confused between the two and say at the police station, I already blew, I’m not blowing again. Which is a mistake, obviously. They’ll get you for a refusal for that. You can actually – which most people wouldn’t know – you can refuse that PAS device. That PAS device is not the most accurate device and that’s really one of the ways to discredit it – the PAS device- which is their own expert – the prosecutor’s own expert is going to have to admit it’s not that accurate.
I’ve been doing this for twenty-five years, and there was a long time you couldn’t even introduce the PAS result in a jury trial, for example, because it’s so unreliable. Now, they’ve given it a little bit more room, but a long of time, I’m seeing the PAS device is one thing, and the breath or blood result is a completely different number. That could be because time passes between the PAS device and then actually doing the test, but it could also be because the PAS device is not a very accurate device. You can get a defense expert to say that without no question and even the prosecutor’s own expert is going to have to admit there are issues with PAS devices.
Another issue to attack and discredit a PAS device in a DUI in Los Angeles is to say that it wasn’t calibrated properly. You have to make sure that thing was working right and the police don’t always do that. If it’s not working right, if it’s taken out of service close in time to when the client has been pulled over for a DUI, then you certainly have the argument that the machine wasn’t working properly, and therefore, that result is not an accurate result.
What ends up happening is, depending on what the PAS device is in comparison to whatever the blow is back at the station or whatever the blood is, you’re going to see both the defense and the prosecution trying to use the PAS device by saying, the PAS device is much closer to the time of driving, so that’s really the accurate result. The prosecutors will say that if, for example, you blow a .08 at the station which is right on the legal limit, and you could probably argue that’s below a .08 if you get a good expert, but if the PAS device is like a .11 or a .10, the prosecutors are going to say, oh yeah, the PAS device is the accurate one because it’s more close to the time of the driving. And defense attorneys do the exact same thing. If the PAS device is a .08 and then you get them back to the station and they’re a .11, the attorney is going to say rising blood alcohol. The PAS device is more accurate. The bottom line is, the PAS device can be discredited. There’s no question, so you hope in your DUI that’s all they have is the PAS device. Then you’re in business. That’s not going to be a good enough test. That’s a winnable DUI case if they’re only using the PAS device.
Where it gets a little bit tricky is if you go to places like Ventura county or even Orange County – in Ventura county, these guys are actually using the device out in the field and that’s how they’re making their determination. They must have a more sophisticated machine out there when they do their tests, but that gets a little bit confusing because they’re not even taking the people back to the station in most cases to do the breath test. So, in that county, there’s all kinds of issues with DUIs and they don’t really negotiate them or Orange County. LA county is much more reasonable. If all you have is the PAS device, you can definitely discredit it with an expert. That’s the main way to discredit it because the expert is going to know how that preliminary screening device is, how it relates to DUIs in Los Angeles and what the problems are with it.
So, if you have a close case – and when I have close DUI cases in LA – I’ll get an expert on board. We’ll show them all the paperwork. I’ll use my twenty-five years of experience. We’ll work together, and if it’s close to the legal limit and there’s problems with that PAS device, then we’re going to attack it and we’re going to try to get that case dismissed. It really just depends on what your blood alcohol level was with the PAS device, what your blood alcohol level was with the blood or breath test, and then you have a discussion with your attorney – I always ask my clients, how much did you drink? What did you drink? How much did you eat? You really have to get into the details of it and see if whatever the PAS device result is – whether it even makes sense in the first place – based on your size, how much alcohol you consumed, how much food you consumed, how much time passed between the driving and using the breath test – and then if there’s any differential between the blood for example, if you took blood and the PAS device, or if there’s any differential between the PAS device and your blow at the station and how much time passed.
There’s all sorts of issued that can be argued. You have to sit down with somebody like me, get the strategy together and then make the right move so you can get the best result in your Los Angeles DUI case.
So, if you have a DUI in California, and specifically, Los Angeles, you’re going to want to get an attorney who has been down this road before and had success. Contact our Los Angeles DUI lawyers to review your case.